Legislating Morality: The Sanction of Marriage


Biologically, a coupling between male and female (with some very rare exceptions like aphids, mites, and some lizards) is required for procreation, critical for survival of the species. On the other hand, marriage is a human social contract, historically accepted as the optimum means of raising offspring who require years of care before they become independent.

Divine blessing on the union is important to many but marriage in the eyes of religion is totally separate from the civil contract of marriage itself. It is the civil contract which has legal standing for government programs like social security and which can be severed by the courts in divorce proceedings. As a social contract between two individuals, the presumption that one must be male and one must be female is irrelevant.

Marriage is certainly an emotional and legal commitment. Once two individuals make the choice that they will spend the rest of their lives together, society approves the decision, notwithstanding the fact that only half of us will be able to permanently remain in that relationship. It is approved because it is a force for stability and responsibility, both vital if a culture is to thrive.

Most married couples have children; many do not. Child rearing is therefore only one aspect of the state of matrimony, not the sole reason for its existence. So why the outcry against same-sex marriage which brings the same forces of stability and responsibility to society as do heterosexual unions?

I suggest that the widespread movement against gay marriage is not really directed at marital vows at all but is a revolt against homosexuality itself. Rather than supporting gays by letting them receive legal sanction for their relationships, we want to punish them. They have stepped outside the bounds of our experience. They make us feel uncomfortable. We see a young man and a girl kissing on the street and smile. We see two young men kissing and emotionally recoil. Most heterosexuals cannot understand gays and unconsciously think that there is "something wrong" with them. (Until 20 years ago, homosexuality was listed as a mental disorder!) If men are from Mars and women are from Venus, gays are from another galaxy.

Because of our discomfort or, in many cases, disgust, we try to legislate them out of existence. The courts, and the culture at large, will not allow us to get rid of them. All we have left is an ability to relegate them to a less-than-equal status by denying them an important social right: marriage. That denial, codified in 11 states on election night, 2004, revealed a fearful desire to legislate morality and conduct according to a pre-conceived idea of what is right and wrong for everyone regardless of their religious, moral, humanistic, or sexual preferences.

The morality crusade that was Prohibition was possibly the most destructive social experiment ever attempted. Not only did it fail to stop the use of alcohol, but led to the rise of organized crime which still holds sway some 80 years later. We can successfully legislate against behaviors that hurt society -- murder, theft, violence and other dangerous acts -- because society benefits when its members are safe and protected.

To suggest that the safety of the world can be threatened by two same-sex individuals reciting vows of commitment before a local official is preposterous. The will to legislate against such an act reflects only our idea to withhold, to punish, to declare before all that it is only our values which matter and that we are right, divinely right.

Virginia Bola is a licensed clinical psychologist with deep interests in Social Psychology and politics. She has performed therapeutic services for more than 20 years and has studied the results of cultural forces and employment on the individual. The author of an interactive workbook, The Wolf at the Door: An Unemployment Survival Manual, and a monthly ezine, The Worker's Edge, she can be reached at http://www.virginiabola.com







Related News



Marriage is a gamble - Straits Times

Marriage is a gamble
Straits Times, Singapore -5 hours ago
She and her fiance are the main draws in Wedding Of The Year, set for release on Jan 22 next year. The film is a black comedy about a celebrity couple who ...

Florida governor's bride-to-be chooses her gown for Dec. 12 wedding - Sun-Sentinel.com

Florida governor's bride-to-be chooses her gown for Dec. 12 wedding
Sun-Sentinel.com, FL -2 hours ago
Hung's salon is also altering cream-colored, floor-length dresses purchased elsewhere for Rome's two preteen daughters from a previous marriage, ...
Gays to Demonstrate at Fla. Gov. Crist’s MarriageEDGE Boston
Gay rights group to protest at Crist's weddingWWSB ABC 7
Sunday links: A protest of the Crist-Rome nuptials?Palm Beach Post
all 22 news articles

Certified Vacations Group, Inc. & CaribbeanWeddings.Com Announce ... - MarketWatch

Certified Vacations Group, Inc. & CaribbeanWeddings.Com Announce ...
MarketWatch -17 hours ago
Certified's 28-year track record of excellence in developing packaged leisure travel, combined with our wedding expertise makes a perfect marriage. ...

Give us an alternative to state-sanctioned marriage - San Francisco Chronicle

Give us an alternative to state-sanctioned marriage
San Francisco Chronicle,  USA -Nov 30, 2008
For us, marriage is not about the big fancy wedding. Marriage is about slowing down long enough to make official what we already know - that these men are ...

Montag, Pratt wedding symbolic, not yet legal - Auburn Citizen

Auburn Citizen

Montag, Pratt wedding symbolic, not yet legal
Auburn Citizen, NY -18 hours ago
The story doesn't note that they had neither obtained a marriage license nor taken part in a separate civil ceremony, which is required by Mexican law to ...
Something Fishy About Spencer - Heidi WeddingTango
all 3 news articles

An ugly attack on Mormons - Los Angeles Times

Hour.ca

An ugly attack on Mormons
Los Angeles Times, CA -2 hours ago
The Mormon zealots yank the couple's wedding rings from their fingers and then tear up their marriage license. As the thugs leave, one says to the other, ...
Sam Loomis '10: Common groundThe Brown Daily Herald
When marriage debate turns ugly, no one winsGrand Junction Free Press
Proposition 8: Separating the fiction from factChristianExaminer
all 63 news articles

Ivana Divorce! Trump Splits From Hubby After 7-Month Marriage - FOXNews

New Zealand Herald

Ivana Divorce! Trump Splits From Hubby After 7-Month Marriage
FOXNews -9 hours ago
Ivana Trump's sons walked her down the aisle, and her daughter Ivanka was her maid of honor for their April 2008 wedding held, to keep the family even more ...
Ivana Trump splits from husband No.4, just seven months after ...Daily Mail
Divorce: Ivana Trump 7 month marriage is overDivorce Diva
Trump separates from fourth husbandNinemsn
all 207 news articles


Florida Governor’s wedding targeted by homosexual activists - Catholic News Agency

Catholic News Agency

Florida Governor’s wedding targeted by homosexual activists
Catholic News Agency, CO -17 minutes ago
... a marriage amendment proposed for the Florida constitution, homosexual activists plan to demonstrate outside the church wedding and reception of Florida ...

Group Plans To Protest Crist's Wedding - CBS 4

Group Plans To Protest Crist's Wedding
CBS 4, FL -10 hours ago
... Impact Florida says the group plans to demonstrate outside Crist's wedding because he supported Amendment 2, which banned same-sex marriage in Florida. ...
Gay Rights Group To Protest At Crist's WeddingCentral Florida News 13|
Gay rights group to protest at Crist's weddingTampabay.com
Gay Rights Protest Set For NuptialsTampa Tribune
all 6 news articles

Weddings and business: A marriage of convenience - BusinessWorld Online

Weddings and business: A marriage of convenience
BusinessWorld Online, Philippines -Nov 27, 2008
Just as weddings are a beginning of a lifelong marriage, wedding suppliers are hopeful that the current business vigor paves the way for a truly sustainable ...